State IntegrityReceipts, not verdicts

Votes · December 2025 · Opposition day motion

Opposition day: Conduct of the Chancellor of the Exchequer: how MPs voted on 10 December 2025

Division 391, 10 December 2025, 18:59. The Commons Votes API gives 90 Ayes, 297 Noes: majority 207 for the Noes.

Ayes
90
Noes
297
Result (Hansard)
Question accordingly negatived.

The question

That this House calls on the Chancellor of the Exchequer to apologise for misleading the country about the state of the public finances, rolling the pitch for raising taxes, breaking her promises and increasing welfare spending, including her claim on 4 November 2025 that the OBR would be downgrading their productivity forecast which, as the Chancellor said, had ‘consequences for the public finances too, in lower tax receipts’, when in fact on 31 October 2025 the OBR had submitted its forecast to the Chancellor that showed tax receipts would be £16 billion higher than previously thought, resulting in the Government’s current balance target being met by a margin of £4.2 billion; further calls on the Chancellor to apologise for breaching the trust of the OBR, whose forecasts are shared in strict confidence until the Chancellor has given her Budget Statement; also calls on the Chancellor to apologise for the misleading briefings and leaks from HM Treasury in advance of the Budget Statement which caused uncertainty for families, businesses and investors; and calls on the Chancellor to apologise for breaking her promise after the last Budget that the Government was not going to raise taxes again, instead raising taxes in the 2025 Budget by £26 billion.

As printed in Hansard before the division.

By party

Conservative MPs cast 86 of the 90 named Aye votes; Labour MPs 291 of the 296 named No votes.

PartyAye (named)No (named)
Labour0291
Conservative860
Independent35
Ulster Unionist Party10
Total90296

Tellers: Jerome Mayhew (Conservative, Broadland and Fakenham) and Gregory Stafford (Conservative, Farnham and Bordon) (Ayes); Mark Ferguson (Labour, Gateshead Central and Whickham) and Taiwo Owatemi (Labour, Coventry North West) (Noes).

How each MP voted

386 named · CSV

MPPartyConstituencyVote
Jack AbbottLabourIpswichNo
Ms Diane AbbottIndependentHackney North and Stoke NewingtonNo
Debbie AbrahamsLabourOldham East and SaddleworthNo
Dr Zubir AhmedLabourGlasgow South WestNo
Luke AkehurstLabourNorth DurhamNo
Mr Bayo AlabaLabourSouthend East and RochfordNo
Heidi AlexanderLabourSwindon SouthNo
Rushanara AliLabourBethnal Green and StepneyNo
Tahir AliLabourBirmingham Hall Green and MoseleyNo
Callum AndersonLabourBuckingham and BletchleyNo
Stuart AndrewConservativeDaventryAye
Edward ArgarConservativeMelton and SystonAye
Dr Scott ArthurLabourEdinburgh South WestNo
Jess AsatoLabourLowestoftNo
Jas AthwalLabourIlford SouthNo
Catherine AtkinsonLabourDerby NorthNo
Lewis AtkinsonLabourSunderland CentralNo
Gareth BaconConservativeOrpingtonAye
Mrs Kemi BadenochConservativeNorth West EssexAye
Mr Calvin BaileyLabourLeyton and WansteadNo
Olivia BaileyLabourReading West and Mid BerkshireNo
Alex BakerLabourAldershotNo
Dame Harriett BaldwinConservativeWest WorcestershireAye
Alex BallingerLabourHalesowenNo
Antonia BanceLabourTipton and WednesburyNo
Steve BarclayConservativeNorth East CambridgeshireAye
Paula BarkerLabourLiverpool WavertreeNo
Lee BarronLabourCorby and East NorthamptonshireNo
Johanna BaxterLabourPaisley and Renfrewshire SouthNo
Danny BealesLabourUxbridge and South RuislipNo
Lorraine BeaversLabourBlackpool North and FleetwoodNo
Mr Peter BedfordConservativeMid LeicestershireAye
Apsana BegumLabourPoplar and LimehouseNo
Torsten BellLabourSwansea WestNo
Mr Clive BettsLabourSheffield South EastNo
Saqib BhattiConservativeMeriden and Solihull EastAye
Ms Polly BillingtonLabourEast ThanetNo
Matt BishopLabourForest of DeanNo
Bob BlackmanConservativeHarrow EastAye
Rachel BlakeLabourCities of London and WestminsterNo
Mrs Elsie BlundellLabourHeywood and Middleton NorthNo
Kevin BonaviaLabourStevenageNo
Sarah BoolConservativeSouth NorthamptonshireAye
Jade BotterillLabourOssett and Denby DaleNo
Andrew BowieConservativeWest Aberdeenshire and KincardineAye
Sureena BrackenridgeLabourWolverhampton North EastNo
Aphra BrandrethConservativeChester South and EddisburyAye
Mr Jonathan BrashLabourHartlepoolNo
Phil BrickellLabourBolton WestNo
Julia BuckleyLabourShrewsburyNo
Alex BurghartConservativeBrentwood and OngarAye
Richard BurgonLabourLeeds EastNo
David Burton-SampsonLabourSouthend West and LeighNo
Dawn ButlerLabourBrent EastNo
Ian ByrneLabourLiverpool West DerbyNo
Nesil CaliskanLabourBarkingNo
Irene CampbellLabourNorth Ayrshire and ArranNo
Juliet CampbellLabourBroxtoweNo
Sir Alan CampbellLabourTynemouthNo
Markus Campbell-SavoursIndependentPenrith and SolwayNo
Dan CardenLabourLiverpool WaltonNo
Al CarnsLabourBirmingham Selly OakNo
Mr Luke ChartersLabourYork OuterNo
Sir James CleverlyConservativeBraintreeAye
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-BrownConservativeNorth CotswoldsAye
Lewis CockingConservativeBroxbourneAye
Jacob CollierLabourBurton and UttoxeterNo
Lizzi CollingeLabourMorecambe and LunesdaleNo
Tom CollinsLabourWorcesterNo
Liam ConlonLabourBeckenham and PengeNo
Andrew CooperLabourMid CheshireNo
Dr Beccy CooperLabourWorthing WestNo
John CooperConservativeDumfries and GallowayAye
Alberto CostaConservativeSouth LeicestershireAye
Deirdre CostiganLabourEaling SouthallNo
Pam CoxLabourColchesterNo
Neil CoyleLabourBermondsey and Old SouthwarkNo
Jen CraftLabourThurrockNo
Ms Stella CreasyLabourWalthamstowNo
Torcuil CrichtonLabourNa h-Eileanan an IarNo
Harriet CrossConservativeGordon and BuchanAye
Chris CurtisLabourMilton Keynes NorthNo
Sir Nicholas DakinLabourScunthorpeNo
Ashley DaltonLabourWest LancashireNo
Emily DarlingtonLabourMilton Keynes CentralNo
Jonathan DaviesLabourMid DerbyshireNo
Paul DaviesLabourColne ValleyNo
Shaun DaviesLabourTelfordNo
Alex Davies-JonesLabourPontypriddNo
Marsha De CordovaLabourBatterseaNo
Josh DeanLabourHertford and StortfordNo
Kate DeardenLabourHalifaxNo
Charlie DewhirstConservativeBridlington and The WoldsAye
Mr Tanmanjeet Singh DhesiLabourSloughNo
Jim DicksonLabourDartfordNo
Dame Caroline DinenageConservativeGosportAye
Anna DixonLabourShipleyNo
Anneliese DoddsLabourOxford EastNo
Helena DollimoreLabourHastings and RyeNo
Peter DowdLabourBootleNo
Graeme DownieLabourDunfermline and DollarNo
Neil Duncan-JordanLabourPooleNo
Dame Angela EagleLabourWallaseyNo
Maria EagleLabourLiverpool GarstonNo
Cat EcclesLabourStourbridgeNo
Lauren EdwardsLabourRochester and StroodNo
Clive EffordLabourEltham and ChislehurstNo
Damien EganLabourBristol North EastNo
Maya EllisLabourRibble ValleyNo
Florence EshalomiLabourVauxhall and Camberwell GreenNo
Bill EstersonLabourSefton CentralNo
Chris EvansLabourCaerphillyNo
Dr Luke EvansConservativeHinckley and BosworthAye
Linsey FarnsworthLabourAmber ValleyNo
Josh Fenton-GlynnLabourCalder ValleyNo
Patricia FergusonLabourGlasgow WestNo
Natalie FleetLabourBolsoverNo
Catherine FookesLabourMonmouthshireNo
Mr Paul FosterLabourSouth RibbleNo
Sir Ashley FoxConservativeBridgwaterAye
Vicky FoxcroftLabourLewisham NorthNo
Mary Kelly FoyLabourCity of DurhamNo
Daniel FrancisLabourBexleyheath and CrayfordNo
Mr Mark FrancoisConservativeRayleigh and WickfordAye
Mr Louie FrenchConservativeOld Bexley and SidcupAye
Mr James FrithLabourBury NorthNo
Gill FurnissLabourSheffield Brightside and HillsboroughNo
Sir Roger GaleConservativeHerne Bay and SandwichAye
Barry GardinerLabourBrent WestNo
Mark GarnierConservativeWyre ForestAye
Anna GelderdLabourSouth East CornwallNo
Alan GemmellLabourCentral AyrshireNo
Gill GermanLabourClwyd NorthNo
Becky GittinsLabourClwyd EastNo
John GlenConservativeSalisburyAye
Mary GlindonLabourNewcastle upon Tyne East and WallsendNo
Ben GoldsboroughLabourSouth NorfolkNo
Jodie GoslingLabourNuneatonNo
John GradyLabourGlasgow EastNo
Helen GrantConservativeMaidstone and MallingAye
Lilian GreenwoodLabourNottingham SouthNo
Dame Nia GriffithLabourLlanelliNo
Alison GriffithsConservativeBognor Regis and LittlehamptonAye
Andrew GwynneIndependentGorton and DentonNo
Amanda HackLabourNorth West LeicestershireNo
Louise HaighLabourSheffield HeeleyNo
Sarah HallLabourWarrington SouthNo
Fabian HamiltonLabourLeeds North EastNo
Paulette HamiltonLabourBirmingham ErdingtonNo
Emma HardyLabourKingston upon Hull West and HaltempriceNo
Carolyn HarrisLabourNeath and Swansea EastNo
Rebecca HarrisConservativeCastle PointAye
Lloyd HattonLabourSouth DorsetNo
Helen HayesLabourDulwich and West NorwoodNo
Sir John HayesConservativeSouth Holland and The DeepingsAye
Tom HayesLabourBournemouth EastNo
Claire HazelgroveLabourFilton and Bradley StokeNo
Sir Mark HendrickLabourPrestonNo
Dame Meg HillierLabourHackney South and ShoreditchNo
Jonathan HinderLabourPendle and ClitheroeNo
Damian HindsConservativeEast HampshireAye
Simon HoareConservativeNorth DorsetAye
Mrs Sharon HodgsonLabourWashington and Gateshead SouthNo
Mr Richard HoldenConservativeBasildon and BillericayAye
Kevin HollinrakeConservativeThirsk and MaltonAye
Paul HolmesConservativeHamble ValleyAye
Rachel HopkinsLabourLuton South and South BedfordshireNo
Nigel HuddlestonConservativeDroitwich and EveshamAye
Dr Neil HudsonConservativeEpping ForestAye
Claire HughesLabourBangor AberconwyNo
Alison HumeLabourScarborough and WhitbyNo
Sir Jeremy HuntConservativeGodalming and AshAye
Dr Rupa HuqLabourEaling Central and ActonNo
Patrick HurleyLabourSouthportNo
Imran HussainLabourBradford EastNo
Mr Adnan HussainIndependentBlackburnAye
Mr Adnan HussainIndependentBlackburnNo
Natasha IronsLabourCroydon EastNo
Dan JarvisLabourBarnsley NorthNo
Sir Bernard JenkinConservativeHarwich and North EssexAye
Robert JenrickConservativeNewarkAye
Terry JermyLabourSouth West NorfolkNo
Adam JogeeLabourNewcastle-under-LymeNo
Kim JohnsonLabourLiverpool RiversideNo
Gerald JonesLabourMerthyr Tydfil and AberdareNo
Lillian JonesLabourKilmarnock and LoudounNo
Ruth JonesLabourNewport West and IslwynNo
Sojan JosephLabourAshfordNo
Warinder JussLabourWolverhampton WestNo
Chris KaneLabourStirling and StrathallanNo
Mike KaneLabourWythenshawe and Sale EastNo
Satvir KaurLabourSouthampton TestNo
Afzal KhanLabourManchester RusholmeNo
Stephen KinnockLabourAberafan MaestegNo
Gen KitchenLabourWellingborough and RushdenNo
Sonia KumarLabourDudleyNo
Uma KumaranLabourStratford and BowNo
Laura Kyrke-SmithLabourAylesburyNo
Peter LambLabourCrawleyNo
John LamontConservativeBerwickshire, Roxburgh and SelkirkAye
Noah LawLabourSt Austell and NewquayNo
Kim LeadbeaterLabourSpen ValleyNo
Sir Edward LeighConservativeGainsboroughAye
Brian LeishmanLabourAlloa and GrangemouthNo
Emma LewellLabourSouth ShieldsNo
Andrew LewinLabourWelwyn HatfieldNo
Clive LewisLabourNorwich SouthNo
Sir Julian LewisConservativeNew Forest EastAye
Rebecca Long BaileyLabourSalfordNo
Julia LopezConservativeHornchurch and UpminsterAye
Josh MacAlisterLabourWhitehaven and WorkingtonNo
Alice MacdonaldLabourNorwich NorthNo
Andy MacNaeLabourRossendale and DarwenNo
Justin MaddersLabourEllesmere Port and BromboroughNo
Alan MakConservativeHavantAye
Kit MalthouseConservativeNorth West HampshireAye
Amanda MartinLabourPortsmouth NorthNo
Rachael MaskellLabourYork CentralNo
Alex MayerLabourDunstable and Leighton BuzzardNo
Douglas McAllisterLabourWest DunbartonshireNo
Martin McCluskeyLabourInverclyde and Renfrewshire WestNo
Andy McDonaldLabourMiddlesbrough and Thornaby EastNo
Chris McDonaldLabourStockton NorthNo
John McDonnellLabourHayes and HarlingtonNo
Blair McDougallLabourEast RenfrewshireNo
Alison McGovernLabourBirkenheadNo
Alex McIntyreLabourGloucesterNo
Gordon McKeeLabourGlasgow SouthNo
Kevin McKennaLabourSittingbourne and SheppeyNo
Catherine McKinnellLabourNewcastle upon Tyne NorthNo
Jim McMahonLabourOldham West, Chadderton and RoytonNo
Anna McMorrinLabourCardiff NorthNo
Frank McNallyLabourCoatbridge and BellshillNo
Anneliese MidgleyLabourKnowsleyNo
Ed MilibandLabourDoncaster NorthNo
Ms Julie MinnsLabourCarlisleNo
Navendu MishraLabourStockportNo
Sir Andrew MitchellConservativeSutton ColdfieldAye
Abtisam MohamedLabourSheffield CentralNo
Iqbal MohamedIndependentDewsbury and BatleyAye
Mr Gagan MohindraConservativeSouth West HertfordshireAye
Robbie MooreConservativeKeighley and IlkleyAye
Jessica MordenLabourNewport EastNo
Stephen MorganLabourPortsmouth SouthNo
Grahame MorrisLabourEasingtonNo
Joe MorrisLabourHexhamNo
Joy MorrisseyConservativeBeaconsfieldAye
Wendy MortonConservativeAldridge-BrownhillsAye
Dr Kieran MullanConservativeBexhill and BattleAye
Luke MurphyLabourBasingstokeNo
Chris MurrayLabourEdinburgh East and MusselburghNo
James MurrayLabourEaling NorthNo
Katrina MurrayLabourCumbernauld and KirkintillochNo
Dr Andrew MurrisonConservativeSouth West WiltshireAye
Luke MyerLabourMiddlesbrough South and East ClevelandNo
Connor NaismithLabourCrewe and NantwichNo
Kanishka NarayanLabourVale of GlamorganNo
Pamela NashLabourMotherwell, Wishaw and CarlukeNo
Josh NewburyLabourCannock ChaseNo
Charlotte NicholsLabourWarrington NorthNo
Jesse NormanConservativeHereford and South HerefordshireAye
Dan NorrisIndependentNorth East Somerset and HanhamNo
Ben Obese-JectyConservativeHuntingdonAye
Melanie OnnLabourGreat Grimsby and CleethorpesNo
Dame Chi OnwurahLabourNewcastle upon Tyne Central and WestNo
Dr Simon OpherLabourStroudNo
Ms Abena Oppong-AsareLabourErith and ThamesmeadNo
Tristan OsborneLabourChatham and AylesfordNo
Sarah OwenLabourLuton NorthNo
Darren PaffeyLabourSouthampton ItchenNo
Andrew PakesLabourPeterboroughNo
Rebecca PaulConservativeReigateAye
Michael PayneLabourGedlingNo
Stephanie PeacockLabourBarnsley SouthNo
Jon PearceLabourHigh PeakNo
Matthew PennycookLabourGreenwich and WoolwichNo
Bridget PhillipsonLabourHoughton and Sunderland SouthNo
Chris PhilpConservativeCroydon SouthAye
David Pinto-DuschinskyLabourHendonNo
Lee PitcherLabourDoncaster East and the Isle of AxholmeNo
Luke PollardLabourPlymouth Sutton and DevonportNo
Joe PowellLabourKensington and BayswaterNo
Lucy PowellLabourManchester CentralNo
Gregor PoyntonLabourLivingstonNo
Dr Peter PrinsleyLabourBury St Edmunds and StowmarketNo
Mark PritchardConservativeThe WrekinAye
Richard QuigleyLabourIsle of Wight WestNo
Yasmin QureshiLabourBolton South and WalkdenNo
Steve RaceLabourExeterNo
Shivani RajaConservativeLeicester EastAye
Andrew RangerLabourWrexhamNo
Jack RankinConservativeWindsorAye
Angela RaynerLabourAshton-under-LyneNo
Mike ReaderLabourNorthampton SouthNo
David ReedConservativeExmouth and Exeter EastAye
Joani ReidLabourEast Kilbride and StrathavenNo
Emma ReynoldsLabourWycombeNo
Jonathan ReynoldsLabourStalybridge and HydeNo
Martin RhodesLabourGlasgow NorthNo
Bell Ribeiro-AddyLabourClapham and Brixton HillNo
Jake RichardsLabourRother ValleyNo
Jenny Riddell-CarpenterLabourSuffolk CoastalNo
Ms Marie RimmerLabourSt Helens South and WhistonNo
Dave RobertsonLabourLichfieldNo
Joe RobertsonConservativeIsle of Wight EastAye
Tim RocaLabourMacclesfieldNo
Andrew RosindellConservativeRomfordAye
Sarah RussellLabourCongletonNo
Sarah SackmanLabourFinchley and Golders GreenNo
Dr Jeevun SandherLabourLoughboroughNo
Louise Sandher-JonesLabourNorth East DerbyshireNo
Mark SewardsLabourLeeds South West and MorleyNo
Baggy ShankerLabourDerby SouthNo
Dr Neil Shastri-HurstConservativeSolihull West and ShirleyAye
Tulip SiddiqLabourHampstead and HighgateNo
David SimmondsConservativeRuislip, Northwood and PinnerAye
Josh SimonsLabourMakerfieldNo
John SlingerLabourRugbyNo
David SmithLabourNorth NorthumberlandNo
Greg SmithConservativeMid BuckinghamshireAye
Rebecca SmithConservativeSouth West DevonAye
Sarah SmithLabourHyndburnNo
Sir Julian SmithConservativeSkipton and RiponAye
Karin SmythLabourBristol SouthNo
Gareth SnellLabourStoke-on-Trent CentralNo
Mr Andrew SnowdenConservativeFyldeAye
Alex SobelLabourLeeds Central and HeadingleyNo
Dr Ben SpencerConservativeRunnymede and WeybridgeAye
Patrick SpencerIndependentCentral Suffolk and North IpswichAye
Euan StainbankLabourFalkirkNo
Blake StephensonConservativeMid BedfordshireAye
Kenneth StevensonLabourAirdrie and ShottsNo
Elaine StewartLabourAyr, Carrick and CumnockNo
Will StoneLabourSwindon NorthNo
Alistair StrathernLabourHitchinNo
Wes StreetingLabourIlford NorthNo
Alan StricklandLabourNewton Aycliffe and SpennymoorNo
Sir Mel StrideConservativeCentral DevonAye
Graham StuartConservativeBeverley and HoldernessAye
Dr Lauren SullivanLabourGraveshamNo
Kirsteen SullivanLabourBathgate and LinlithgowNo
Peter SwallowLabourBracknellNo
Robin SwannUlster Unionist PartySouth AntrimAye
Sir Desmond SwayneConservativeNew Forest WestAye
David TaylorLabourHemel HempsteadNo
Rachel TaylorLabourNorth Warwickshire and BedworthNo
Bradley ThomasConservativeBromsgroveAye
Adam ThompsonLabourErewashNo
Dr Marie TidballLabourPenistone and StocksbridgeNo
Sir Stephen TimmsLabourEast HamNo
Nick TimothyConservativeWest SuffolkAye
Dan TomlinsonLabourChipping BarnetNo
Jon TrickettLabourNormanton and HemsworthNo
Laura TrottConservativeSevenoaksAye
Henry TufnellLabourMid and South PembrokeshireNo
Tom TugendhatConservativeTonbridgeAye
Matt TurmaineLabourWatfordNo
Laurence TurnerLabourBirmingham NorthfieldNo
Liz TwistLabourBlaydon and ConsettNo
Harpreet UppalLabourHuddersfieldNo
Valerie VazLabourWalsall and BloxwichNo
Martin VickersConservativeBrigg and ImminghamAye
Chris VinceLabourHarlowNo
Chris WardLabourBrighton Kemptown and PeacehavenNo
Melanie WardLabourCowdenbeath and KirkcaldyNo
Paul WaughLabourRochdaleNo
Chris WebbLabourBlackpool SouthNo
Andrew WesternLabourStretford and UrmstonNo
Matt WesternLabourWarwick and LeamingtonNo
Helen WhatelyConservativeFaversham and Mid KentAye
Michael WheelerLabourWorsley and EcclesNo
John WhitbyLabourDerbyshire DalesNo
Jo WhiteLabourBassetlawNo
Katie WhiteLabourLeeds North WestNo
Sir John WhittingdaleConservativeMaldonAye
James WildConservativeNorth West NorfolkAye
David WilliamsLabourStoke-on-Trent NorthNo
Steve WitherdenLabourMontgomeryshire and GlyndŵrNo
Mike WoodConservativeKingswinford and South StaffordshireAye
Sean WoodcockLabourBanburyNo
Sir Jeremy WrightConservativeKenilworth and SouthamAye
Rosie WrightingLabourKetteringNo
Yuan YangLabourEarley and WoodleyNo
Mohammad YasinLabourBedfordNo
Steve YemmLabourMansfieldNo
Daniel ZeichnerLabourCambridgeNo

Sources

SHA-256 of each copy read. Open Parliament Licence v3.0

Method · Report an error