Votes · November 2025 · Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Act 2025 · Lords amendments

Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 43: how MPs voted on 5 November 2025

Division 344, 5 November 2025, 18:48. The Commons Votes API gives 268 Ayes, 80 Noes: majority 188 for the Ayes.

Ayes

268

Noes

Result (Hansard)

Question accordingly agreed to.

By party

Labour MPs cast 264 of the 267 named Aye votes; Liberal Democrat MPs 61 of the 80 named No votes.

Party	Aye (named)	No (named)
Labour	264	1
Liberal Democrat	0	61
Independent	3	5
Green Party	0	4
Plaid Cymru	0	4
Scottish National Party	0	4
Democratic Unionist Party	0	1
Total	267	80

Tellers: Jade Botterill (Labour, Ossett and Denby Dale) and Mark Ferguson (Labour, Gateshead Central and Whickham) (Ayes); Tessa Munt (Liberal Democrat, Wells and Mendip Hills) and Claire Young (Liberal Democrat, Thornbury and Yate) (Noes).

How each MP voted

347 named · CSV

MP	Party	Constituency	Vote
Jack Abbott	Labour	Ipswich	Aye
Shockat Adam	Independent	Leicester South	No
Luke Akehurst	Labour	North Durham	Aye
Sadik Al-Hassan	Labour	North Somerset	Aye
Mr Bayo Alaba	Labour	Southend East and Rochford	Aye
Dan Aldridge	Labour	Weston-super-Mare	Aye
Heidi Alexander	Labour	Swindon South	Aye
Rushanara Ali	Labour	Bethnal Green and Stepney	Aye
Tahir Ali	Labour	Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley	Aye
Gideon Amos	Liberal Democrat	Taunton and Wellington	No
Callum Anderson	Labour	Buckingham and Bletchley	Aye
Fleur Anderson	Labour	Putney	Aye
Steff Aquarone	Liberal Democrat	North Norfolk	No
Dr Scott Arthur	Labour	Edinburgh South West	Aye
Jess Asato	Labour	Lowestoft	Aye
James Asser	Labour	West Ham and Beckton	Aye
Jas Athwal	Labour	Ilford South	Aye
Catherine Atkinson	Labour	Derby North	Aye
Lewis Atkinson	Labour	Sunderland Central	Aye
Josh Babarinde	Liberal Democrat	Eastbourne	No
Mr Calvin Bailey	Labour	Leyton and Wanstead	Aye
Olivia Bailey	Labour	Reading West and Mid Berkshire	Aye
David Baines	Labour	St Helens North	Aye
Alex Ballinger	Labour	Halesowen	Aye
Antonia Bance	Labour	Tipton and Wednesbury	Aye
Lee Barron	Labour	Corby and East Northamptonshire	Aye
Mr Alex Barros-Curtis	Labour	Cardiff West	Aye
Johanna Baxter	Labour	Paisley and Renfrewshire South	Aye
Danny Beales	Labour	Uxbridge and South Ruislip	Aye
Lorraine Beavers	Labour	Blackpool North and Fleetwood	Aye
Apsana Begum	Labour	Poplar and Limehouse	No
Torsten Bell	Labour	Swansea West	Aye
Alison Bennett	Liberal Democrat	Mid Sussex	No
Siân Berry	Green Party	Brighton Pavilion	No
Ms Polly Billington	Labour	East Thanet	Aye
Kirsty Blackman	Scottish National Party	Aberdeen North	No
Olivia Blake	Labour	Sheffield Hallam	Aye
Rachel Blake	Labour	Cities of London and Westminster	Aye
Mrs Elsie Blundell	Labour	Heywood and Middleton North	Aye
Kevin Bonavia	Labour	Stevenage	Aye
Sureena Brackenridge	Labour	Wolverhampton North East	Aye
Phil Brickell	Labour	Bolton West	Aye
Julia Buckley	Labour	Shrewsbury	Aye
Liam Byrne	Labour	Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North	Aye
Nesil Caliskan	Labour	Barking	Aye
Irene Campbell	Labour	North Ayrshire and Arran	Aye
Juliet Campbell	Labour	Broxtowe	Aye
Markus Campbell-Savours	Labour	Penrith and Solway	Aye
Charlotte Cane	Liberal Democrat	Ely and East Cambridgeshire	No
Dan Carden	Labour	Liverpool Walton	Aye
Sam Carling	Labour	North West Cambridgeshire	Aye
David Chadwick	Liberal Democrat	Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe	No
Wendy Chamberlain	Liberal Democrat	North East Fife	No
Dr Danny Chambers	Liberal Democrat	Winchester	No
Sarah Champion	Labour	Rotherham	Aye
Bambos Charalambous	Labour	Southgate and Wood Green	Aye
Mr Luke Charters	Labour	York Outer	Aye
Dr Ellie Chowns	Green Party	North Herefordshire	No
Chris Coghlan	Liberal Democrat	Dorking and Horley	No
Ben Coleman	Labour	Chelsea and Fulham	Aye
Jacob Collier	Labour	Burton and Uttoxeter	Aye
Lizzi Collinge	Labour	Morecambe and Lunesdale	Aye
Tom Collins	Labour	Worcester	Aye
Victoria Collins	Liberal Democrat	Harpenden and Berkhamsted	No
Sarah Coombes	Labour	West Bromwich	Aye
Andrew Cooper	Labour	Mid Cheshire	Aye
Daisy Cooper	Liberal Democrat	St Albans	No
Dr Beccy Cooper	Labour	Worthing West	Aye
Deirdre Costigan	Labour	Ealing Southall	Aye
Pam Cox	Labour	Colchester	Aye
Neil Coyle	Labour	Bermondsey and Old Southwark	Aye
Jen Craft	Labour	Thurrock	Aye
Mary Creagh	Labour	Coventry East	Aye
Ms Stella Creasy	Labour	Walthamstow	Aye
Chris Curtis	Labour	Milton Keynes North	Aye
Janet Daby	Labour	Lewisham East	Aye
Ashley Dalton	Labour	West Lancashire	Aye
Adam Dance	Liberal Democrat	Yeovil	No
Steve Darling	Liberal Democrat	Torbay	No
Emily Darlington	Labour	Milton Keynes Central	Aye
Ed Davey	Liberal Democrat	Kingston and Surbiton	No
Ann Davies	Plaid Cymru	Caerfyrddin	No
Jonathan Davies	Labour	Mid Derbyshire	Aye
Paul Davies	Labour	Colne Valley	Aye
Shaun Davies	Labour	Telford	Aye
Alex Davies-Jones	Labour	Pontypridd	Aye
Bobby Dean	Liberal Democrat	Carshalton and Wallington	No
Josh Dean	Labour	Hertford and Stortford	Aye
Carla Denyer	Green Party	Bristol Central	No
Jim Dickson	Labour	Dartford	Aye
Mr Lee Dillon	Liberal Democrat	Newbury	No
Anna Dixon	Labour	Shipley	Aye
Anneliese Dodds	Labour	Oxford East	Aye
Helena Dollimore	Labour	Hastings and Rye	Aye
Stephen Doughty	Labour	Cardiff South and Penarth	Aye
Peter Dowd	Labour	Bootle	Aye
Graeme Downie	Labour	Dunfermline and Dollar	Aye
Rosie Duffield	Independent	Canterbury	No
Sarah Dyke	Liberal Democrat	Glastonbury and Somerton	No
Dame Angela Eagle	Labour	Wallasey	Aye
Maria Eagle	Labour	Liverpool Garston	Aye
Cat Eccles	Labour	Stourbridge	Aye
Sarah Edwards	Labour	Tamworth	Aye
Damien Egan	Labour	Bristol North East	Aye
Maya Ellis	Labour	Ribble Valley	Aye
Kirith Entwistle	Labour	Bolton North East	Aye
Florence Eshalomi	Labour	Vauxhall and Camberwell Green	Aye
Bill Esterson	Labour	Sefton Central	Aye
Miatta Fahnbulleh	Labour	Peckham	Aye
Mr Hamish Falconer	Labour	Lincoln	Aye
Linsey Farnsworth	Labour	Amber Valley	Aye
Tim Farron	Liberal Democrat	Westmorland and Lonsdale	No
Josh Fenton-Glynn	Labour	Calder Valley	Aye
Patricia Ferguson	Labour	Glasgow West	Aye
Natalie Fleet	Labour	Bolsover	Aye
Emma Foody	Labour	Cramlington and Killingworth	Aye
Catherine Fookes	Labour	Monmouthshire	Aye
Richard Foord	Liberal Democrat	Honiton and Sidmouth	No
Mr Will Forster	Liberal Democrat	Woking	No
Mr Paul Foster	Labour	South Ribble	Aye
Vicky Foxcroft	Labour	Lewisham North	Aye
Zöe Franklin	Liberal Democrat	Guildford	No
Gill Furniss	Labour	Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough	Aye
Dr Allison Gardner	Labour	Stoke-on-Trent South	Aye
Alan Gemmell	Labour	Central Ayrshire	Aye
Andrew George	Liberal Democrat	St Ives	No
Gill German	Labour	Clwyd North	Aye
Sarah Gibson	Liberal Democrat	Chippenham	No
Tracy Gilbert	Labour	Edinburgh North and Leith	Aye
Preet Kaur Gill	Labour	Birmingham Edgbaston	Aye
Rachel Gilmour	Liberal Democrat	Tiverton and Minehead	No
Becky Gittins	Labour	Clwyd East	Aye
Mary Glindon	Labour	Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend	Aye
Olly Glover	Liberal Democrat	Didcot and Wantage	No
Marie Goldman	Liberal Democrat	Chelmsford	No
Ben Goldsborough	Labour	South Norfolk	Aye
Sarah Green	Liberal Democrat	Chesham and Amersham	No
Lilian Greenwood	Labour	Nottingham South	Aye
Dame Nia Griffith	Labour	Llanelli	Aye
Andrew Gwynne	Independent	Gorton and Denton	Aye
Amanda Hack	Labour	North West Leicestershire	Aye
Sarah Hall	Labour	Warrington South	Aye
Fabian Hamilton	Labour	Leeds North East	Aye
Paulette Hamilton	Labour	Birmingham Erdington	Aye
Monica Harding	Liberal Democrat	Esher and Walton	No
Carolyn Harris	Labour	Neath and Swansea East	Aye
Tom Hayes	Labour	Bournemouth East	Aye
Claire Hazelgrove	Labour	Filton and Bradley Stoke	Aye
Sir Mark Hendrick	Labour	Preston	Aye
Dame Meg Hillier	Labour	Hackney South and Shoreditch	Aye
Jonathan Hinder	Labour	Pendle and Clitheroe	Aye
Wera Hobhouse	Liberal Democrat	Bath	No
Rachel Hopkins	Labour	Luton South and South Bedfordshire	Aye
Claire Hughes	Labour	Bangor Aberconwy	Aye
Dr Rupa Huq	Labour	Ealing Central and Acton	Aye
Patrick Hurley	Labour	Southport	Aye
Mr Adnan Hussain	Independent	Blackburn	No
Leigh Ingham	Labour	Stafford	Aye
Natasha Irons	Labour	Croydon East	Aye
Liz Jarvis	Liberal Democrat	Eastleigh	No
Dame Diana Johnson	Labour	Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham	Aye
Kim Johnson	Labour	Liverpool Riverside	Aye
Clive Jones	Liberal Democrat	Wokingham	No
Lillian Jones	Labour	Kilmarnock and Loudoun	Aye
Ruth Jones	Labour	Newport West and Islwyn	Aye
Gurinder Singh Josan	Labour	Smethwick	Aye
Sojan Joseph	Labour	Ashford	Aye
Chris Kane	Labour	Stirling and Strathallan	Aye
Mike Kane	Labour	Wythenshawe and Sale East	Aye
Satvir Kaur	Labour	Southampton Test	Aye
Naushabah Khan	Labour	Gillingham and Rainham	Aye
Stephen Kinnock	Labour	Aberafan Maesteg	Aye
Jayne Kirkham	Labour	Truro and Falmouth	Aye
Gen Kitchen	Labour	Wellingborough and Rushden	Aye
Mr Paul Kohler	Liberal Democrat	Wimbledon	No
Sonia Kumar	Labour	Dudley	Aye
Uma Kumaran	Labour	Stratford and Bow	Aye
Laura Kyrke-Smith	Labour	Aylesbury	Aye
Ben Lake	Plaid Cymru	Ceredigion Preseli	No
Peter Lamb	Labour	Crawley	Aye
Ian Lavery	Labour	Blyth and Ashington	Aye
Chris Law	Scottish National Party	Dundee Central	No
Noah Law	Labour	St Austell and Newquay	Aye
Kim Leadbeater	Labour	Spen Valley	Aye
Andrew Lewin	Labour	Welwyn Hatfield	Aye
Clive Lewis	Labour	Norwich South	Aye
Simon Lightwood	Labour	Wakefield and Rothwell	Aye
Rebecca Long Bailey	Labour	Salford	Aye
Josh MacAlister	Labour	Whitehaven and Workington	Aye
James MacCleary	Liberal Democrat	Lewes	No
Alice Macdonald	Labour	Norwich North	Aye
Mr Angus MacDonald	Liberal Democrat	Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire	No
Andy MacNae	Labour	Rossendale and Darwen	Aye
Justin Madders	Labour	Ellesmere Port and Bromborough	Aye
Ben Maguire	Liberal Democrat	North Cornwall	No
Helen Maguire	Liberal Democrat	Epsom and Ewell	No
Amanda Martin	Labour	Portsmouth North	Aye
Mike Martin	Liberal Democrat	Tunbridge Wells	No
Rachael Maskell	Independent	York Central	Aye
Keir Mather	Labour	Selby	Aye
Brian Mathew	Liberal Democrat	Melksham and Devizes	No
Alex Mayer	Labour	Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard	Aye
Charlie Maynard	Liberal Democrat	Witney	No
Douglas McAllister	Labour	West Dunbartonshire	Aye
Kerry McCarthy	Labour	Bristol East	Aye
Martin McCluskey	Labour	Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West	Aye
Dame Siobhain McDonagh	Labour	Mitcham and Morden	Aye
Andy McDonald	Labour	Middlesbrough and Thornaby East	Aye
Pat McFadden	Labour	Wolverhampton South East	Aye
Alex McIntyre	Labour	Gloucester	Aye
Gordon McKee	Labour	Glasgow South	Aye
Kevin McKenna	Labour	Sittingbourne and Sheppey	Aye
Jim McMahon	Labour	Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton	Aye
Llinos Medi	Plaid Cymru	Ynys Môn	No
Anneliese Midgley	Labour	Knowsley	Aye
Calum Miller	Liberal Democrat	Bicester and Woodstock	No
John Milne	Liberal Democrat	Horsham	No
Ms Julie Minns	Labour	Carlisle	Aye
Navendu Mishra	Labour	Stockport	Aye
Iqbal Mohamed	Independent	Dewsbury and Batley	No
Perran Moon	Labour	Camborne and Redruth	Aye
Layla Moran	Liberal Democrat	Oxford West and Abingdon	No
Jessica Morden	Labour	Newport East	Aye
Edward Morello	Liberal Democrat	West Dorset	No
Helen Morgan	Liberal Democrat	North Shropshire	No
Grahame Morris	Labour	Easington	Aye
Tom Morrison	Liberal Democrat	Cheadle	No
Margaret Mullane	Labour	Dagenham and Rainham	Aye
Susan Murray	Liberal Democrat	Mid Dunbartonshire	No
Luke Myer	Labour	Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland	Aye
James Naish	Labour	Rushcliffe	Aye
Connor Naismith	Labour	Crewe and Nantwich	Aye
Kanishka Narayan	Labour	Vale of Glamorgan	Aye
Josh Newbury	Labour	Cannock Chase	Aye
Samantha Niblett	Labour	South Derbyshire	Aye
Charlotte Nichols	Labour	Warrington North	Aye
Alex Norris	Labour	Nottingham North and Kimberley	Aye
Dan Norris	Independent	North East Somerset and Hanham	Aye
Brendan O'Hara	Scottish National Party	Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber	No
Sarah Olney	Liberal Democrat	Richmond Park	No
Dame Chi Onwurah	Labour	Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West	Aye
Dr Simon Opher	Labour	Stroud	Aye
Ms Abena Oppong-Asare	Labour	Erith and Thamesmead	Aye
Kate Osamor	Labour	Edmonton and Winchmore Hill	Aye
Tristan Osborne	Labour	Chatham and Aylesford	Aye
Taiwo Owatemi	Labour	Coventry North West	Aye
Darren Paffey	Labour	Southampton Itchen	Aye
Andrew Pakes	Labour	Peterborough	Aye
Matthew Patrick	Labour	Wirral West	Aye
Michael Payne	Labour	Gedling	Aye
Stephanie Peacock	Labour	Barnsley South	Aye
Manuela Perteghella	Liberal Democrat	Stratford-on-Avon	No
Jess Phillips	Labour	Birmingham Yardley	Aye
Bridget Phillipson	Labour	Houghton and Sunderland South	Aye
Dr Al Pinkerton	Liberal Democrat	Surrey Heath	No
David Pinto-Duschinsky	Labour	Hendon	Aye
Lee Pitcher	Labour	Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme	Aye
Jo Platt	Labour	Leigh and Atherton	Aye
Joe Powell	Labour	Kensington and Bayswater	Aye
Lucy Powell	Labour	Manchester Central	Aye
Gregor Poynton	Labour	Livingston	Aye
Dr Peter Prinsley	Labour	Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket	Aye
Yasmin Qureshi	Labour	Bolton South and Walkden	Aye
Steve Race	Labour	Exeter	Aye
Adrian Ramsay	Green Party	Waveney Valley	No
Mr Connor Rand	Labour	Altrincham and Sale West	Aye
Andrew Ranger	Labour	Wrexham	Aye
Angela Rayner	Labour	Ashton-under-Lyne	Aye
Mike Reader	Labour	Northampton South	Aye
Joani Reid	Labour	East Kilbride and Strathaven	Aye
Jonathan Reynolds	Labour	Stalybridge and Hyde	Aye
Mr Joshua Reynolds	Liberal Democrat	Maidenhead	No
Jenny Riddell-Carpenter	Labour	Suffolk Coastal	Aye
Tim Roca	Labour	Macclesfield	Aye
Matt Rodda	Labour	Reading Central	Aye
Ian Roome	Liberal Democrat	North Devon	No
Dr Sam Rushworth	Labour	Bishop Auckland	Aye
Sarah Russell	Labour	Congleton	Aye
Oliver Ryan	Labour	Burnley	Aye
Dr Jeevun Sandher	Labour	Loughborough	Aye
Liz Saville Roberts	Plaid Cymru	Dwyfor Meirionnydd	No
Mark Sewards	Labour	Leeds South West and Morley	Aye
Baggy Shanker	Labour	Derby South	Aye
Jim Shannon	Democratic Unionist Party	Strangford	No
Tulip Siddiq	Labour	Hampstead and Highgate	Aye
Josh Simons	Labour	Makerfield	Aye
Vikki Slade	Liberal Democrat	Mid Dorset and North Poole	No
Andy Slaughter	Labour	Hammersmith and Chiswick	Aye
John Slinger	Labour	Rugby	Aye
Cat Smith	Labour	Lancaster and Wyre	Aye
David Smith	Labour	North Northumberland	Aye
Jeff Smith	Labour	Manchester Withington	Aye
Nick Smith	Labour	Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney	Aye
Gareth Snell	Labour	Stoke-on-Trent Central	Aye
Ian Sollom	Liberal Democrat	St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire	No
Euan Stainbank	Labour	Falkirk	Aye
Kenneth Stevenson	Labour	Airdrie and Shotts	Aye
Jamie Stone	Liberal Democrat	Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross	No
Will Stone	Labour	Swindon North	Aye
Wes Streeting	Labour	Ilford North	Aye
Alan Strickland	Labour	Newton Aycliffe and Spennymoor	Aye
Dr Lauren Sullivan	Labour	Gravesham	Aye
Kirsteen Sullivan	Labour	Bathgate and Linlithgow	Aye
Zarah Sultana	Independent	Coventry South	No
Peter Swallow	Labour	Bracknell	Aye
Sir Mark Tami	Labour	Alyn and Deeside	Aye
Mike Tapp	Labour	Dover and Deal	Aye
David Taylor	Labour	Hemel Hempstead	Aye
Luke Taylor	Liberal Democrat	Sutton and Cheam	No
Cameron Thomas	Liberal Democrat	Tewkesbury	No
Fred Thomas	Labour	Plymouth Moor View	Aye
Gareth Thomas	Labour	Harrow West	Aye
Adam Thompson	Labour	Erewash	Aye
Sir Stephen Timms	Labour	East Ham	Aye
Jessica Toale	Labour	Bournemouth West	Aye
Jon Trickett	Labour	Normanton and Hemsworth	Aye
Henry Tufnell	Labour	Mid and South Pembrokeshire	Aye
Anna Turley	Labour	Redcar	Aye
Matt Turmaine	Labour	Watford	Aye
Laurence Turner	Labour	Birmingham Northfield	Aye
Liz Twist	Labour	Blaydon and Consett	Aye
Harpreet Uppal	Labour	Huddersfield	Aye
Freddie van Mierlo	Liberal Democrat	Henley and Thame	No
Tony Vaughan	Labour	Folkestone and Hythe	Aye
Valerie Vaz	Labour	Walsall and Bloxwich	Aye
Chris Vince	Labour	Harlow	Aye
Caroline Voaden	Liberal Democrat	South Devon	No
Christian Wakeford	Labour	Bury South	Aye
Chris Ward	Labour	Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven	Aye
Michelle Welsh	Labour	Sherwood Forest	Aye
Catherine West	Labour	Hornsey and Friern Barnet	Aye
Andrew Western	Labour	Stretford and Urmston	Aye
Matt Western	Labour	Warwick and Leamington	Aye
Michael Wheeler	Labour	Worsley and Eccles	Aye
John Whitby	Labour	Derbyshire Dales	Aye
Jo White	Labour	Bassetlaw	Aye
Max Wilkinson	Liberal Democrat	Cheltenham	No
David Williams	Labour	Stoke-on-Trent North	Aye
Munira Wilson	Liberal Democrat	Twickenham	No
Pete Wishart	Scottish National Party	Perth and Kinross-shire	No
Steve Witherden	Labour	Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr	Aye
Sean Woodcock	Labour	Banbury	Aye
Martin Wrigley	Liberal Democrat	Newton Abbot	No
Yuan Yang	Labour	Earley and Woodley	Aye
Mohammad Yasin	Labour	Bedford	Aye
Steve Yemm	Labour	Mansfield	Aye
Daniel Zeichner	Labour	Cambridge	Aye

Sources

Bill: Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Act 2025
Hansard: Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill
Commons division 344
Commons Votes API: division 0806c3ee8330c095 15 October 2026
Hansard API: division search ac37c3ae6cf70e5b 15 October 2026

SHA-256 of each copy read. Open Parliament Licence v3.0

Method · Report an error