State IntegrityReceipts, not verdicts

Votes · May 2025 · Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 · Amendment

Data (Use and Access) Bill Report Stage: New Clause 2: how MPs voted on 7 May 2025

Division 188, 7 May 2025, 18:14. The Commons Votes API gives 88 Ayes, 287 Noes: majority 199 for the Noes.

Ayes
88
Noes
287
Result (Hansard)
Question accordingly negatived.

The question

New Clause 2

Compliance with UK copyright law by operators of web crawlers and general-purpose AI models

“(1) The Secretary of State must by regulations make provision (including any such provision as might be made by Act of Parliament), requiring the operators of web crawlers and general-purpose artificial intelligence (AI) models whose services have links with the United Kingdom within the meaning of section 4(5) of the Online Safety Act 2023 to comply with United Kingdom copyright law, including the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, regardless of the jurisdiction in which the copyright-relevant acts relating to the pre-training, development and operation of those web crawlers and general-purpose AI models take place.

(2) Provision made under subsection (1) must apply to the entire lifecycle of a general-purpose AI model, including but not limited to—

(a) pre-training and training,

(b) fine tuning,

(c) grounding and retrieval-augmented generation, and

(d) the collection of data for the said purposes.

(3) The Secretary of State must lay before Parliament a draft of the statutory instrument containing regulations under subsection (1) within six months of the day on which this Act is passed and the regulations are subject to the affirmative procedure.”.—(Victoria Collins.)

This new clause requires web crawlers and general-purpose AI models with UK links to comply with UK copyright law across all stages of AI development.

Brought up.

Question put, That the clause be added to the Bill.

As printed in Hansard before the division.

By party

Liberal Democrat MPs cast 54 of the 88 named Aye votes; Labour MPs 284 of the 286 named No votes.

PartyAye (named)No (named)
Labour0284
Liberal Democrat540
Independent82
Conservative60
Scottish National Party60
Green Party40
Plaid Cymru40
Reform UK30
Democratic Unionist Party10
Social Democratic & Labour Party10
Traditional Unionist Voice10
Total88286

Tellers: Tessa Munt (Liberal Democrat, Wells and Mendip Hills) and Susan Murray (Liberal Democrat, Mid Dunbartonshire) (Ayes); Anna McMorrin (Labour, Cardiff North) and Gen Kitchen (Labour, Wellingborough and Rushden) (Noes).

How each MP voted

374 named · CSV

MPPartyConstituencyVote
Jack AbbottLabourIpswichNo
Ms Diane AbbottLabourHackney North and Stoke NewingtonNo
Debbie AbrahamsLabourOldham East and SaddleworthNo
Shockat AdamIndependentLeicester SouthAye
Dr Zubir AhmedLabourGlasgow South WestNo
Sadik Al-HassanLabourNorth SomersetNo
Dan AldridgeLabourWeston-super-MareNo
Tahir AliLabourBirmingham Hall Green and MoseleyNo
Dr Rosena Allin-KhanLabourTootingNo
Jim AllisterTraditional Unionist VoiceNorth AntrimAye
Gideon AmosLiberal DemocratTaunton and WellingtonAye
Callum AndersonLabourBuckingham and BletchleyNo
Lee AndersonReform UKAshfieldAye
Steff AquaroneLiberal DemocratNorth NorfolkAye
Dr Scott ArthurLabourEdinburgh South WestNo
Jess AsatoLabourLowestoftNo
James AsserLabourWest Ham and BecktonNo
Jas AthwalLabourIlford SouthNo
Lewis AtkinsonLabourSunderland CentralNo
Josh BabarindeLiberal DemocratEastbourneAye
Olivia BaileyLabourReading West and Mid BerkshireNo
David BainesLabourSt Helens NorthNo
Richard BakerLabourGlenrothes and Mid FifeNo
Alex BallingerLabourHalesowenNo
Antonia BanceLabourTipton and WednesburyNo
Paula BarkerLabourLiverpool WavertreeNo
Lee BarronLabourCorby and East NorthamptonshireNo
Mr Alex Barros-CurtisLabourCardiff WestNo
Johanna BaxterLabourPaisley and Renfrewshire SouthNo
Danny BealesLabourUxbridge and South RuislipNo
Lorraine BeaversLabourBlackpool North and FleetwoodNo
Apsana BegumIndependentPoplar and LimehouseAye
Torsten BellLabourSwansea WestNo
Alison BennettLiberal DemocratMid SussexAye
Siân BerryGreen PartyBrighton PavilionAye
Mr Clive BettsLabourSheffield South EastNo
Ms Polly BillingtonLabourEast ThanetNo
Matt BishopLabourForest of DeanNo
Kirsty BlackmanScottish National PartyAberdeen NorthAye
Olivia BlakeLabourSheffield HallamNo
Rachel BlakeLabourCities of London and WestminsterNo
Chris BlooreLabourRedditchNo
Mrs Elsie BlundellLabourHeywood and Middleton NorthNo
Kevin BonaviaLabourStevenageNo
Jade BotterillLabourOssett and Denby DaleNo
Sureena BrackenridgeLabourWolverhampton North EastNo
Mr Jonathan BrashLabourHartlepoolNo
Alex BrewerLiberal DemocratNorth East HampshireAye
Phil BrickellLabourBolton WestNo
Jess Brown-FullerLiberal DemocratChichesterAye
Chris BryantLabourRhondda and OgmoreNo
Julia BuckleyLabourShrewsburyNo
Richard BurgonLabourLeeds EastNo
Maureen BurkeLabourGlasgow North EastNo
Dawn ButlerLabourBrent EastNo
Ian ByrneLabourLiverpool West DerbyNo
Liam ByrneLabourBirmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull NorthNo
Nesil CaliskanLabourBarkingNo
Irene CampbellLabourNorth Ayrshire and ArranNo
Sir Alan CampbellLabourTynemouthNo
Markus Campbell-SavoursLabourPenrith and SolwayNo
Charlotte CaneLiberal DemocratEly and East CambridgeshireAye
Dan CardenLabourLiverpool WaltonNo
Al CarnsLabourBirmingham Selly OakNo
David ChadwickLiberal DemocratBrecon, Radnor and Cwm TaweAye
Wendy ChamberlainLiberal DemocratNorth East FifeAye
Dr Danny ChambersLiberal DemocratWinchesterAye
Sarah ChampionLabourRotherhamNo
Bambos CharalambousLabourSouthgate and Wood GreenNo
Dr Ellie ChownsGreen PartyNorth HerefordshireAye
Chris CoghlanLiberal DemocratDorking and HorleyAye
Jacob CollierLabourBurton and UttoxeterNo
Lizzi CollingeLabourMorecambe and LunesdaleNo
Tom CollinsLabourWorcesterNo
Victoria CollinsLiberal DemocratHarpenden and BerkhamstedAye
Liam ConlonLabourBeckenham and PengeNo
Sarah CoombesLabourWest BromwichNo
Andrew CooperLabourMid CheshireNo
Daisy CooperLiberal DemocratSt AlbansAye
Dr Beccy CooperLabourWorthing WestNo
Deirdre CostiganLabourEaling SouthallNo
Pam CoxLabourColchesterNo
Neil CoyleLabourBermondsey and Old SouthwarkNo
Jen CraftLabourThurrockNo
Torcuil CrichtonLabourNa h-Eileanan an IarNo
Chris CurtisLabourMilton Keynes NorthNo
Janet DabyLabourLewisham EastNo
Sir Nicholas DakinLabourScunthorpeNo
Ashley DaltonLabourWest LancashireNo
Adam DanceLiberal DemocratYeovilAye
Steve DarlingLiberal DemocratTorbayAye
Emily DarlingtonLabourMilton Keynes CentralNo
Ed DaveyLiberal DemocratKingston and SurbitonAye
Ann DaviesPlaid CymruCaerfyrddinAye
Jonathan DaviesLabourMid DerbyshireNo
Paul DaviesLabourColne ValleyNo
Bobby DeanLiberal DemocratCarshalton and WallingtonAye
Josh DeanLabourHertford and StortfordNo
Kate DeardenLabourHalifaxNo
Carla DenyerGreen PartyBristol CentralAye
Mr Tanmanjeet Singh DhesiLabourSloughNo
Jim DicksonLabourDartfordNo
Mr Lee DillonLiberal DemocratNewburyAye
Dame Caroline DinenageConservativeGosportAye
Anna DixonLabourShipleyNo
Samantha DixonLabourChester North and NestonNo
Anneliese DoddsLabourOxford EastNo
Dave DooganScottish National PartyAngus and Perthshire GlensAye
Peter DowdLabourBootleNo
Graeme DownieLabourDunfermline and DollarNo
Rosie DuffieldIndependentCanterburyAye
Sir Iain Duncan SmithConservativeChingford and Woodford GreenAye
Dame Angela EagleLabourWallaseyNo
Colum EastwoodSocial Democratic & Labour PartyFoyleAye
Cat EcclesLabourStourbridgeNo
Lauren EdwardsLabourRochester and StroodNo
Sarah EdwardsLabourTamworthNo
Clive EffordLabourEltham and ChislehurstNo
Maya EllisLabourRibble ValleyNo
Chris ElmoreLabourBridgendNo
Bill EstersonLabourSefton CentralNo
Chris EvansLabourCaerphillyNo
Mr Hamish FalconerLabourLincolnNo
Linsey FarnsworthLabourAmber ValleyNo
Tim FarronLiberal DemocratWestmorland and LonsdaleAye
Josh Fenton-GlynnLabourCalder ValleyNo
Mark FergusonLabourGateshead Central and WhickhamNo
Patricia FergusonLabourGlasgow WestNo
Natalie FleetLabourBolsoverNo
Stephen FlynnScottish National PartyAberdeen SouthAye
Emma FoodyLabourCramlington and KillingworthNo
Catherine FookesLabourMonmouthshireNo
Richard FoordLiberal DemocratHoniton and SidmouthAye
Mr Will ForsterLiberal DemocratWokingAye
Mr Paul FosterLabourSouth RibbleNo
Vicky FoxcroftLabourLewisham NorthNo
Daniel FrancisLabourBexleyheath and CrayfordNo
Zöe FranklinLiberal DemocratGuildfordAye
Barry GardinerLabourBrent WestNo
Dr Allison GardnerLabourStoke-on-Trent SouthNo
Anna GelderdLabourSouth East CornwallNo
Stephen GethinsScottish National PartyArbroath and Broughty FerryAye
Sarah GibsonLiberal DemocratChippenhamAye
Becky GittinsLabourClwyd EastNo
Olly GloverLiberal DemocratDidcot and WantageAye
Marie GoldmanLiberal DemocratChelmsfordAye
Ben GoldsboroughLabourSouth NorfolkNo
Tom GordonLiberal DemocratHarrogate and KnaresboroughAye
John GradyLabourGlasgow EastNo
Sarah GreenLiberal DemocratChesham and AmershamAye
Lilian GreenwoodLabourNottingham SouthNo
Andrew GwynneIndependentGorton and DentonNo
Amanda HackLabourNorth West LeicestershireNo
Louise HaighLabourSheffield HeeleyNo
Fabian HamiltonLabourLeeds North EastNo
Paulette HamiltonLabourBirmingham ErdingtonNo
Monica HardingLiberal DemocratEsher and WaltonAye
Emma HardyLabourKingston upon Hull West and HaltempriceNo
Carolyn HarrisLabourNeath and Swansea EastNo
Lloyd HattonLabourSouth DorsetNo
Claire HazelgroveLabourFilton and Bradley StokeNo
John HealeyLabourRawmarsh and ConisbroughNo
Sir Mark HendrickLabourPrestonNo
Pippa HeylingsLiberal DemocratSouth CambridgeshireAye
Dame Meg HillierLabourHackney South and ShoreditchNo
Chris HinchliffLabourNorth East HertfordshireNo
Rachel HopkinsLabourLuton South and South BedfordshireNo
Claire HughesLabourBangor AberconwyNo
Dr Rupa HuqLabourEaling Central and ActonNo
Patrick HurleyLabourSouthportNo
Imran HussainLabourBradford EastNo
Mr Adnan HussainIndependentBlackburnAye
Natasha IronsLabourCroydon EastNo
Sally JamesonLabourDoncaster CentralNo
Christine JardineLiberal DemocratEdinburgh WestAye
Liz JarvisLiberal DemocratEastleighAye
Terry JermyLabourSouth West NorfolkNo
Adam JogeeLabourNewcastle-under-LymeNo
Kim JohnsonLabourLiverpool RiversideNo
Clive JonesLiberal DemocratWokinghamAye
Gerald JonesLabourMerthyr Tydfil and AberdareNo
Louise Sandher-JonesLabourNorth East DerbyshireNo
Sarah JonesLabourCroydon WestNo
Sojan JosephLabourAshfordNo
Warinder JussLabourWolverhampton WestNo
Chris KaneLabourStirling and StrathallanNo
Mike KaneLabourWythenshawe and Sale EastNo
Satvir KaurLabourSouthampton TestNo
Afzal KhanLabourManchester RusholmeNo
Ayoub KhanIndependentBirmingham Perry BarrAye
Naushabah KhanLabourGillingham and RainhamNo
Stephen KinnockLabourAberafan MaestegNo
Jayne KirkhamLabourTruro and FalmouthNo
Sonia KumarLabourDudleyNo
Uma KumaranLabourStratford and BowNo
Peter KyleLabourHove and PortsladeNo
Laura Kyrke-SmithLabourAylesburyNo
Ben LakePlaid CymruCeredigion PreseliAye
Peter LambLabourCrawleyNo
Ian LaveryLabourBlyth and AshingtonNo
Chris LawScottish National PartyDundee CentralAye
Noah LawLabourSt Austell and NewquayNo
Kim LeadbeaterLabourSpen ValleyNo
Emma LewellLabourSouth ShieldsNo
Andrew LewinLabourWelwyn HatfieldNo
Clive LewisLabourNorwich SouthNo
Simon LightwoodLabourWakefield and RothwellNo
Alice MacdonaldLabourNorwich NorthNo
Andy MacNaeLabourRossendale and DarwenNo
Justin MaddersLabourEllesmere Port and BromboroughNo
Ben MaguireLiberal DemocratNorth CornwallAye
Seema MalhotraLabourFeltham and HestonNo
Kit MalthouseConservativeNorth West HampshireAye
Amanda MartinLabourPortsmouth NorthNo
Mike MartinLiberal DemocratTunbridge WellsAye
Rachael MaskellLabourYork CentralNo
Keir MatherLabourSelbyNo
Brian MathewLiberal DemocratMelksham and DevizesAye
Alex MayerLabourDunstable and Leighton BuzzardNo
Charlie MaynardLiberal DemocratWitneyAye
Douglas McAllisterLabourWest DunbartonshireNo
Dame Siobhain McDonaghLabourMitcham and MordenNo
Andy McDonaldLabourMiddlesbrough and Thornaby EastNo
Chris McDonaldLabourStockton NorthNo
John McDonnellIndependentHayes and HarlingtonAye
Lola McEvoyLabourDarlingtonNo
Pat McFaddenLabourWolverhampton South EastNo
Alison McGovernLabourBirkenheadNo
Alex McIntyreLabourGloucesterNo
Gordon McKeeLabourGlasgow SouthNo
Catherine McKinnellLabourNewcastle upon Tyne NorthNo
Jim McMahonLabourOldham West, Chadderton and RoytonNo
James McMurdockReform UKSouth Basildon and East ThurrockAye
Frank McNallyLabourCoatbridge and BellshillNo
Kirsty McNeillLabourMidlothianNo
Esther McVeyConservativeTattonAye
Llinos MediPlaid CymruYnys MônAye
Anneliese MidgleyLabourKnowsleyNo
Navendu MishraLabourStockportNo
Abtisam MohamedLabourSheffield CentralNo
Iqbal MohamedIndependentDewsbury and BatleyAye
Perran MoonLabourCamborne and RedruthNo
Layla MoranLiberal DemocratOxford West and AbingdonAye
Jessica MordenLabourNewport EastNo
Edward MorelloLiberal DemocratWest DorsetAye
Stephen MorganLabourPortsmouth SouthNo
Grahame MorrisLabourEasingtonNo
Joe MorrisLabourHexhamNo
Tom MorrisonLiberal DemocratCheadleAye
Luke MurphyLabourBasingstokeNo
Ian MurrayLabourEdinburgh SouthNo
James MurrayLabourEaling NorthNo
Luke MyerLabourMiddlesbrough South and East ClevelandNo
James NaishLabourRushcliffeNo
Connor NaismithLabourCrewe and NantwichNo
Kanishka NarayanLabourVale of GlamorganNo
Josh NewburyLabourCannock ChaseNo
Charlotte NicholsLabourWarrington NorthNo
Sarah OlneyLiberal DemocratRichmond ParkAye
Dame Chi OnwurahLabourNewcastle upon Tyne Central and WestNo
Dr Simon OpherLabourStroudNo
Ms Abena Oppong-AsareLabourErith and ThamesmeadNo
Kate OsborneLabourJarrow and Gateshead EastNo
Tristan OsborneLabourChatham and AylesfordNo
Taiwo OwatemiLabourCoventry North WestNo
Sarah OwenLabourLuton NorthNo
Darren PaffeyLabourSouthampton ItchenNo
Michael PayneLabourGedlingNo
Jon PearceLabourHigh PeakNo
Matthew PennycookLabourGreenwich and WoolwichNo
Mr Toby PerkinsLabourChesterfieldNo
Manuela PerteghellaLiberal DemocratStratford-on-AvonAye
Jess PhillipsLabourBirmingham YardleyNo
Bridget PhillipsonLabourHoughton and Sunderland SouthNo
Lee PitcherLabourDoncaster East and the Isle of AxholmeNo
Jo PlattLabourLeigh and AthertonNo
Sarah PochinReform UKRuncorn and HelsbyAye
Joe PowellLabourKensington and BayswaterNo
Lucy PowellLabourManchester CentralNo
Gregor PoyntonLabourLivingstonNo
Dr Peter PrinsleyLabourBury St Edmunds and StowmarketNo
Richard QuigleyLabourIsle of Wight WestNo
Yasmin QureshiLabourBolton South and WalkdenNo
Steve RaceLabourExeterNo
Adrian RamsayGreen PartyWaveney ValleyAye
Mike ReaderLabourNorthampton SouthNo
Mr Joshua ReynoldsLiberal DemocratMaidenheadAye
Martin RhodesLabourGlasgow NorthNo
Bell Ribeiro-AddyLabourClapham and Brixton HillNo
Jake RichardsLabourRother ValleyNo
Jenny Riddell-CarpenterLabourSuffolk CoastalNo
Lucy RigbyLabourNorthampton NorthNo
Ms Marie RimmerLabourSt Helens South and WhistonNo
Dave RobertsonLabourLichfieldNo
Tim RocaLabourMacclesfieldNo
Matt RoddaLabourReading CentralNo
Dr Sam RushworthLabourBishop AucklandNo
Sarah RussellLabourCongletonNo
Tom RutlandLabourEast Worthing and ShorehamNo
Oliver RyanIndependentBurnleyNo
Dr Jeevun SandherLabourLoughboroughNo
Liz Saville RobertsPlaid CymruDwyfor MeirionnyddAye
Michelle ScroghamLabourBarrow and FurnessNo
Mark SewardsLabourLeeds South West and MorleyNo
Naz ShahLabourBradford WestNo
Jim ShannonDemocratic Unionist PartyStrangfordAye
Tulip SiddiqLabourHampstead and HighgateNo
Josh SimonsLabourMakerfieldNo
Vikki SladeLiberal DemocratMid Dorset and North PooleAye
Andy SlaughterLabourHammersmith and ChiswickNo
John SlingerLabourRugbyNo
Lisa SmartLiberal DemocratHazel GroveAye
Cat SmithLabourLancaster and WyreNo
David SmithLabourNorth NorthumberlandNo
Jeff SmithLabourManchester WithingtonNo
Nick SmithLabourBlaenau Gwent and RhymneyNo
Sir Julian SmithConservativeSkipton and RiponAye
Gareth SnellLabourStoke-on-Trent CentralNo
Ian SollomLiberal DemocratSt Neots and Mid CambridgeshireAye
Euan StainbankLabourFalkirkNo
Jo StevensLabourCardiff EastNo
Kenneth StevensonLabourAirdrie and ShottsNo
Jamie StoneLiberal DemocratCaithness, Sutherland and Easter RossAye
Will StoneLabourSwindon NorthNo
Wes StreetingLabourIlford NorthNo
Alan StricklandLabourNewton Aycliffe and SpennymoorNo
Zarah SultanaIndependentCoventry SouthAye
Sir Mark TamiLabourAlyn and DeesideNo
Mike TappLabourDover and DealNo
Alison TaylorLabourPaisley and Renfrewshire NorthNo
David TaylorLabourHemel HempsteadNo
Luke TaylorLiberal DemocratSutton and CheamAye
Rachel TaylorLabourNorth Warwickshire and BedworthNo
Cameron ThomasLiberal DemocratTewkesburyAye
Adam ThompsonLabourErewashNo
Dr Marie TidballLabourPenistone and StocksbridgeNo
Sir Stephen TimmsLabourEast HamNo
Jessica ToaleLabourBournemouth WestNo
Dan TomlinsonLabourChipping BarnetNo
Jon TrickettLabourNormanton and HemsworthNo
Henry TufnellLabourMid and South PembrokeshireNo
Anna TurleyLabourRedcarNo
Matt TurmaineLabourWatfordNo
Karl TurnerLabourKingston upon Hull EastNo
Laurence TurnerLabourBirmingham NorthfieldNo
Liz TwistLabourBlaydon and ConsettNo
Harpreet UppalLabourHuddersfieldNo
Freddie van MierloLiberal DemocratHenley and ThameAye
Tony VaughanLabourFolkestone and HytheNo
Valerie VazLabourWalsall and BloxwichNo
Chris VinceLabourHarlowNo
Caroline VoadenLiberal DemocratSouth DevonAye
Christian WakefordLabourBury SouthNo
Chris WardLabourBrighton Kemptown and PeacehavenNo
Paul WaughLabourRochdaleNo
Chris WebbLabourBlackpool SouthNo
Michelle WelshLabourSherwood ForestNo
Catherine WestLabourHornsey and Friern BarnetNo
Andrew WesternLabourStretford and UrmstonNo
Michael WheelerLabourWorsley and EcclesNo
John WhitbyLabourDerbyshire DalesNo
Jo WhiteLabourBassetlawNo
Katie WhiteLabourLeeds North WestNo
Sir John WhittingdaleConservativeMaldonAye
Max WilkinsonLiberal DemocratCheltenhamAye
Munira WilsonLiberal DemocratTwickenhamAye
Pete WishartScottish National PartyPerth and Kinross-shireAye
Steve WitherdenLabourMontgomeryshire and GlyndŵrNo
Sean WoodcockLabourBanburyNo
Rosie WrightingLabourKetteringNo
Martin WrigleyLiberal DemocratNewton AbbotAye
Yuan YangLabourEarley and WoodleyNo
Mohammad YasinLabourBedfordNo
Claire YoungLiberal DemocratThornbury and YateAye

Sources

SHA-256 of each copy read. Open Parliament Licence v3.0

Method · Report an error